Is it a Roger Waters solo album or a Pink Floyd album? Let’s, for a while, try to divorce the album itself from the bad feelings around it’s creation.
It’s hard, for me at least, to discuss the final cut without also mentioning The Wall and The Pros And Cons Of Hitch-hiking. A lot of the music on all three albums originates from the same set of 1977-78 demos. Roger came to the band with two concepts in ’78 for consideration as the next Pink Floyd album. The Wall and The Pros And Cons Of Hitch-Hiking. The band thought that The Wall had more potential so went with that. As you already know, Waters went with “Hitch-Hiking” as his first solo album in ’84.
If you listen to all three albums, it is very clear that they all share little musical phrases and leitmotifs with each other. Three albums drawn from the same well. Keep in mind that the Wall demos were only about 40 minutes long and the argument concerning whether or not Roger locked the band out of contributing music to the project…. there was lots of room for contribution, but, as Gilmour has said in the past (and Waters), he’s rather lazy when it comes to writing and he just didn’t have a lot of stuff around to give to Roger to work with, so Waters wrote the majority of the music. And Waters (and Gilmour too) were disappointed in Wright because he hadn’t contributed any original music whatsoever since Wish You Were Here.
In short, I take the band’s argument about Roger’s dictatorship and Roger’s argument about no one else contributing and rest my conclusion somewhere in the middle. After all, Gilmour wrote some of the best bits on The Wall and was a very vocal co-producer responsible for a lot of how the finished album sounded. I just think the same thing could’ve happened for the final cut as well and therefore it could’ve been a stronger “pink floyd” album as a result. But I could be wrong. I wasn’t there you know!
As it is… The album to follow up from The Wall album and film was originally to be a sort of “soundtrack” album including newly recorded songs from the film and some of the leftovers from the original demos. So some of the album is leftover demos but the rest was some new tracks and themes that were a direct reaction to Thatcher’s Falklands war. So now we have:
Pink Floyd – The Final Cut (1983)

a requiem for the postwar dream. for eric fletcher waters. 1913-1944
Continue reading “PINK FLOYD’s Forgotten Albums #4: The Final Cut (1983)” »